How devices are tested
The short version
Reviews here are subjective, first-hand impressions from real daily use — not lab measurements. What makes them useful is context and honesty: every page states exactly what was tested, with what gear, for how long, and what wasn't tested at all.
Status labels
- tested — used long enough for a confident verdict. Only these get ratings.
- in-progress — currently being tested; impressions may change.
- notes-only — early first-hand impressions, explicitly not a full review.
- not-reviewed — tracked (e.g. wishlist) but zero first-hand claims are made.
- owned — bought and kept; long-term use.
- borrowed / demoed — limited time with the device; treated with extra caution.
- community submitted — a reader's written impressions, labeled and never scored.
- wishlist — not in hand; nothing on the page is a judgment of sound.
Testing context
Every full review documents:
- the room(s) and listening environment,
- source devices and connection modes (Bluetooth codec, wired, USB…),
- the music and media types used,
- total time with the device,
- and — just as important — what was not tested.
Scoring
Tested devices get an overall rating out of 10 plus sub-scores for sound, comfort, build, features, and value. Scores are relative to price class and use case, not absolute. Untested devices never get numbers — the content system refuses ratings on anything not marked as tested.
What this site will not do
- Publish reviews of devices nobody here has used.
- Generate listening impressions with AI.
- Take sponsorships that influence verdicts (any sponsorship would be disclosed on the page).
- Quietly rewrite verdicts — corrections and changes show up in each page's update history.